Thursday 9 February 2012

Matchday 24: Busy week if you're a football journalist...

'Arry - from following the reports coming out the courtroom, it was pretty clear to me that he was gonna be acquitted. To be overly simplistic, the key argument for me was why someone who pays a hell of a lot in income tax each year would try to fiddle the system for a few thousand? I also disagree with the argument that the £8m spent on the prosecution was a waste - ultimately, if HMRC & the CPS thought it was worth pursuing then that's that - you can't put a price on justice in my opinion. The problem comes when the police seemed to think that the case they had built was strong enough to press charges - clearly they were wrong by the failure to get a conviction at both trials. That is where changes need to be made, not in the finances. To impose some arbitrary limit on how much can be spent to investigate a crime seems ridiculous; I don't see how you could hamstring the police like that in future.

UPDATE: HMRC/CPS have stated that the total cost (to date) was £1.3m. Point still stands however

Capello - as a self avowed "give 2 hoots about England" kinda guy, I'm amazed how much I care. The FA have cocked this up big time - if they wanted to sort out the Terry captaincy situation, then it should have been done when the CPS first got involved, not 3 months later. I don't see how Terry could have remained as captain with this over him - that's not to prejudice the court case, but to be captain, you have to be a leader, be respected by the squad, be able to stand up and face the world as a representative of the team. Ideally, he would have stepped down himself, much as Chris Huhne (hahahaha) did to "clear his name". In reality, it's because being a leader in the public eye means you have to keep your life whiter than white - unfair, perhaps but that's how the world works.

I don't blame Capello for feeling aggrieved that he was undermined by the FA, and having read Marcotti's transcript of his Italian interview, I don't think that what he said was too bad - I think this was the straw that broke the camel's back and the media and the FA can pat each other's backs for getting rid of a manager better than England could have hoped for or deserved.

Finally, Man Utd vs Liverpool on Saturday - anyone want to predict how many fans are going to disgrace themselves by "defending" Evra or Suarez? Will they even shake hands? I'm pretty sick of the whole thing - my view is that Evra is a prick and undoubtedly provoked Suarez (hardly out of character) but Suarez clearly used unacceptable language and deserved a ban. He also has failed to apologise to Evra for that, and comes away from this with his reputation deservedly poo-brown. Dalglish and Liverpool's continued "Luis is the victim" shtick is tiresome and has lost them the support of the neutral.

Would be interested to hear anyone's views in the comments, through twitter or by facebook is anyone wants to reply.

Enough ranting - predictions:

Man Utd vs Liverpool - MAN UTD
Blackburn vs QPR - QPR
Bolton vs Wigan - WIGAN
Everton vs Chelsea - DRAW
Fulham vs Stoke - DRAW
Sunderland vs Arsenal - ARSENAL
Swansea vs Norwich - SWANSEA
Spurs vs Newcastle - DRAW
Wolves vs WBA - WOLVES
Aston Villa vs Man City - MAN CITY

Total odds: 15, 401/1 with Paddypower

Predictions in the comments below as per usual, good luck!

17 comments:

Nick said...

Vitriol from CC. Personally I agree with your Redknapp paragraphs. Not sure I agree with your vilification of the FA. McNulty wrote an interesting piece about how Bernstein was hamstrung from the off because of the cock-up with Fabio's contract. Meant that, according to McNulty, Bernstein is walking in someone else's shoes. And, whilst Fab's words weren't fire and brimstone, it's clear that Bernstein et al. had already had a chat with the manager about doing just that: they accepted his disagreement, and he should accept theirs with him.

More to the point, however, why on earth is there an England captain who doesn't like to be touched by two English players, let alone be led by the guy? It's one thing to have an on field spat between opposing teams, but another that you can't shake hands afterwards. Terry can't hold his head up high (particularly knowing, as he does, that his actions can condemn him, even without evidence, a la his 'fling' with the former Mistress Bridge).

As for Suarez and Evra. Agreed. What I hated was Dalglish's 'you're sullying* the character of a reputable player'. Bollocks, in short. Suarez had already been banned in another country for biting another player -- otherwise known as a criminal act -- and also for swearing at opposition fans in England. His character was already sullied before his speech.

That is all; your rant rewarded with one of my own.

*Dalglish probably didn't use the word 'sully'. I paraphrase.

Man Utd vs Liverpool - MAN UTD
Blackburn vs QPR - QPR
Bolton vs Wigan - BOLTON
Everton vs Chelsea - EVERTON
Fulham vs Stoke - FULHAM
Sunderland vs Arsenal - ARSENAL
Swansea vs Norwich - SWANSEA
Spurs vs Newcastle - SPURS
Wolves vs WBA - DRAW
Aston Villa vs Man City - MAN CITY

Yanik said...

Man Utd vs Liverpool - DRAW
Blackburn vs QPR - QPR
Bolton vs Wigan - BOLTON
Everton vs Chelsea - CHELSEA
Fulham vs Stoke - FULHAM
Sunderland vs Arsenal - ARSENAL
Swansea vs Norwich - SWANSEA
Spurs vs Newcastle - DRAW
Wolves vs WBA - WOLVES
Aston Villa vs Man City - MAN CITY

'Arry - Agree with you on everything, except that no-one has yet explained to my satisfaction why his Monaco account is in his dog's name. Does that not REEK of something underhanded to anyone else? But yes, why try and and play a fast one on a matter of ~£80,000 in tax when you earn millions a year anyway.

Capello - People seem to have forgotten he was actually a good manager, with statistically the best record in fact (other than actually winning a trophy). His team even beat Spain - no matter how lucky, how many teams can claim to have done that recently. Since the world cup disaster, I think he's been building something new and better, and I would have liked to have seen how that had gone. No doubt, the new manager will get the credit. If it's 'arry, the media might even lay off the team long enough for them to get some confidence back.

The FA - cocked it right up. If they wanted to dump Terry (rightly, he's a cancer), they should have found a way to do it so it appeared to come from Fabio. Difficult I know, when he'd already stated his position the other way, but it was his choice as manager.

Evra/Suarez - should take a running jump off a cliff, preferably with JT. WHAT a c*nty triad. And to take up Nick's point, they all have been for a long time, and football would be a better place without them.

Jonathan said...

Man Utd vs Liverpool - LIVERPOOL
Blackburn vs QPR - DRAW
Bolton vs Wigan - BOLTON
Everton vs Chelsea - CHELSEA
Fulham vs Stoke - FULHAM
Sunderland vs Arsenal - ARSENAL
Swansea vs Norwich - SWANSEA
Spurs vs Newcastle - SPURS
Wolves vs WBA - DRAW
Aston Villa vs Man City - MAN CITY

Odds: 1942.66 - 1 on Paddypower

Anonymous said...

Man Utd vs Liverpool - MAN UTD
Blackburn vs QPR - QPR
Bolton vs Wigan - BOLTON
Everton vs Chelsea - EVERTON
Fulham vs Stoke - STOKE
Sunderland vs Arsenal - ARSENAL
Swansea vs Norwich - SWANSEA
Spurs vs Newcastle - SPURS
Wolves vs WBA - WOLVES
Aston Villa vs Man City - MAN CITY

Josh B

Joel Salomon said...

Can I add this: If I hear another person use the 'innocent until proven guilty' line once more then I may have to go and shoot someone. In any workplace, if charges are brought against you then your work will most likely suspend you on full pay. In that respect, Terry is still a footballer, just not a captain. (agree with you Rich about the leadership whiter than white malarky)

Am miffed as to how Terry's counsel/Chelsea were able to move the trial until after the Euros?

CPS need their heads examining. Not about the money(although 1.5 million!!) but how they assess the evidence. Between you and me, I spoke with two High Court Judges about two weeks ago, both of whom laughed away the case. Even if he had been found guilty (Harry), then a fine would have been imposed rather than custodial sentence.

Anywho..
Man Utd vs Liverpool - MANU
Blackburn vs QPR - QPR
Bolton vs Wigan - BOLTON
Everton vs Chelsea - EVERTON
Fulham vs Stoke - FULHAM
Sunderland vs Arsenal - DRAW
Swansea vs Norwich - DRAW
Spurs vs Newcastle - SPURS
Wolves vs WBA - WBA
Aston Villa vs Man City - MAN CITY

Joe6725 said...

Man Utd vs Liverpool - MAN UTD
Blackburn vs QPR - BLACKBURN
Bolton vs Wigan - DRAW
Everton vs Chelsea - CHELSEA
Fulham vs Stoke - FULHAM
Sunderland vs Arsenal - ARSENAL
Swansea vs Norwich - SWANSEA
Spurs vs Newcastle - SPURS
Wolves vs WBA - WBA
Aston Villa vs Man City - MAN CITY

1921/1

Daniel said...

Man Utd vs Liverpool - LIVERPOOL
Blackburn vs QPR - DRAW
Bolton vs Wigan - BOLTON
Everton vs Chelsea - DRAW
Fulham vs Stoke - DRAW
Sunderland vs Arsenal - SUNDERLAND
Swansea vs Norwich - SWANSEA
Spurs vs Newcastle - SPURS
Wolves vs WBA - WOLVES
Aston Villa vs Man City - MAN CITY

WIGGI said...

Man Utd vs Liverpool - MAN UTD
Blackburn vs QPR - QPR
Bolton vs Wigan - DRAW
Everton vs Chelsea - CHELSEA
Fulham vs Stoke - FULHAM
Sunderland vs Arsenal - ARSENAL
Swansea vs Norwich - DRAW
Spurs vs Newcastle - SPURS
Wolves vs WBA - WBA
Aston Villa vs Man City - MAN CITY

Naph said...

Man Utd vs Liverpool - MAN UTD
Blackburn vs QPR - QPR
Bolton vs Wigan - DRAW
Everton vs Chelsea - CHELSEA
Fulham vs Stoke - DRAW
Sunderland vs Arsenal - DRAW
Swansea vs Norwich - SWANSEA
Spurs vs Newcastle - SPURS
Wolves vs WBA - WOLVES
Aston Villa vs Man City - MAN CITY

4905/1 @PP

JT said...

Man Utd vs Liverpool - MAN UTD
Blackburn vs QPR - QPR
Bolton vs Wigan - WIGAN
Everton vs Chelsea - EVERTON
Fulham vs Stoke - STOKE
Sunderland vs Arsenal - ARSENAL
Swansea vs Norwich - SWANSEA
Spurs vs Newcastle - DRAW
Wolves vs WBA - DRAW
Aston Villa vs Man City - MAN CITY

24,742/1 (PP) - these seem long odds even by my standards!

Sam Ruback said...

Man Utd vs Liverpool - MAN UTD
Blackburn vs QPR - QPR
Bolton vs Wigan - BOLTON
Everton vs Chelsea - DRAW
Fulham vs Stoke - FULHAM
Sunderland vs Arsenal - ARSENAL
Swansea vs Norwich - SWANSEA
Spurs vs Newcastle - SPURS
Wolves vs WBA - WOLVES
Aston Villa vs Man City - MAN CITY
2060/1

Doron said...

Man Utd vs Liverpool - United
Blackburn vs QPR - Blackburn
Bolton vs Wigan - Bolton
Everton vs Chelsea - Everton
Fulham vs Stoke - Fulham
Sunderland vs Arsenal - Sunderland
Swansea vs Norwich - Swansea
Spurs vs Newcastle - Spurs
Wolves vs WBA - West Brom
Aston Villa vs Man City - Draw

6209.2/1 with PP

Will O'Doherty said...

Man Utd vs Liverpool - MAN UTD
Blackburn vs QPR - QPR
Bolton vs Wigan - WIGAN
Everton vs Chelsea - EVERTON
Fulham vs Stoke - DRAW
Sunderland vs Arsenal - DRAW
Swansea vs Norwich - SWANSEA
Spurs vs Newcastle - SPURS
Wolves vs WBA - WOLVES
Aston Villa vs Man City - MAN CITY

Odds: 16,780/1

Feneley said...

Man Utd vs Liverpool - MAN UTD
Blackburn vs QPR - DRAW
Bolton vs Wigan - BOLTON
Everton vs Chelsea - CHELSEA
Fulham vs Stoke - DRAW
Sunderland vs Arsenal - ARSENAL
Swansea vs Norwich - SWANSEA
Spurs vs Newcastle - SPURS
Wolves vs WBA - DRAW
Aston Villa vs Man City - MAN CITY

2511/1 on Mark Jarvis

Grabs said...

Man Utd vs Liverpool - MAN UTD
Blackburn vs QPR - DRAW
Bolton vs Wigan - WIGAN
Everton vs Chelsea - CHELSEA
Fulham vs Stoke - STOKE
Sunderland vs Arsenal - DRAW
Swansea vs Norwich - SWANSEA
Spurs vs Newcastle - SPURS
Wolves vs WBA - WOLVES
Aston Villa vs Man City - MAN CITY

Dan Davis said...

Man Utd vs Liverpool - MAN UTD
Blackburn vs QPR - DRAW
Bolton vs Wigan - BOLTON
Everton vs Chelsea - CHELSEA
Fulham vs Stoke - FULHAM
Sunderland vs Arsenal - ARSENAL
Swansea vs Norwich - SWANSEA
Spurs vs Newcastle - SPURS
Wolves vs WBA - WOLVES
Aston Villa vs Man City - MAN CITY

Ryan Wain said...

Man Utd vs Liverpool - LIVERPOOL
Blackburn vs QPR - QPR
Bolton vs Wigan - BOLTON
Everton vs Chelsea - CHELSEA
Fulham vs Stoke - FULHAM
Sunderland vs Arsenal - DRAW
Swansea vs Norwich - SWANSEA
Spurs vs Newcastle - DRAW
Wolves vs WBA - WBA
Aston Villa vs Man City - MAN CITY

12,443.34/1